Trayvon and Abdulrahman

The name Trayvon, sadly, has become a household name in the U.S., and elsewhere. But many of you may not know the name Abdulrahman. Both young men, though, were U.S. citizens born in 1995, and both were tragically killed – but in greatly different circumstances.

Trayvon Martin, as you know, was killed at short range in February 2012 by George Zimmerman. Abdulrahman al-Awlaki, as you may not know, was killed at very long range by a U.S. drone.

Abdulrahman was born in Denver, Colo. in September 1995, nine months after Trayvon; he was killed in Yemen on Oct. 14, 2011, ten weeks before the Florida teenager was shot and killed.

Abdulrahman

The justification of Trayvon’s slaying is highly questionable, although the jury concluded that under Florida law Zimmerman was not guilty of second degree murder or manslaughter.

The killing of Abdulrahman, though, seems completely unjustified and an unmitigated tragedy. It is hard to compare justification for taking someone’s life, but the killing of Abdulrahman seems much more unjust that the “self-defense” killing of Trayvon.

Abdulrahman’s father, Anwar, was also an American citizen, born in New Mexico in 1971. And he was killed by a “Hellfire missile” fired from a U. S. Predator drone just two weeks before his son.

The father was clearly linked to terrorist activity. There is no evidence at all that the son was.

Details of Abdulrahman’s tragic death are told in Jeremy Scahill’s 2013 book, “Dirty Wars: The World Is a Battlefield.” The final chapter of that 642-page book is “Paying for the Sins of the Father” and is about Abdulrahman’s annihilation.

On June 28, I attended the opening screening of Scahill’s documentary film with the same name as the book. In it, Scahill interviews Nasser al-Awlaki, Abdulrahman’s grandfather, who is a former Fulbright scholar, university president and Yemeni public servant.

Last week the New York Times ran an article by Grandfather Nasser. It was titled “The Drone That Killed My Grandson.” I encourage you to read that article at this link.

Even though Abdulrahman’s father was involved in terrorist activities, he was an American citizen. Nevertheless, he was never charged with a crime and evidence of his criminal wrongdoing was never presented to a court.

He was just put on a kill list and “taken out” by a drone.

Still, we have been in a “war on terrorism” since 2001, and in a war you target and kill your enemies. So most Americans probably support the killing of Abdulrahman’s father.

And most Americans support continuation of the war on terrorism, according to a Fox News poll. Last month after President Obama said that the war on terrorism “must end,” 77% of the voters polled said the war on terrorism “should continue to be a top priority to the government.

But should that mean targeting and killing a 16-year-old American boy? Surely not!

In responding to questions about his killing, Robert Gibbs, a former White House press secretary, said that the boy should have had “a more responsible father.”

But maybe we need a more responsible government. And maybe there needs to be more outrage about the killing of Abdulrahman.

Many of us are against profiling and the mistreatment of young African-American men like Trayvon, as we should be.

Why shouldn’t we be even more strongly against the profiling and the killing of a young Yemeni-American man like Abdulrahman?

Note: This blog posting – and more than 300 others – can also be found at http://theviewfromthisseat.blogspot.com

Advertisements

About Leroy Seat

* Born in Grant City, MO, on 8/15/1938 * Graduated from Southwest Baptist College (Bolivar, MO) in 1957 (A.A.) * Graduated from William Jewell College (Liberty, MO) in 1959 (A.B.) * Graduated from The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary (Louisville, KY) in 1962 (B.D., equivalent of M.Div.) * Received the Doctor of Philosophy degree in theology from SBTS. * Baptist missionary to Japan from 1966 to 2004. * Full-time faculty member at Seinan Gakuin University (Fukuoka, Japan) from 1968 to 2004. * Adjunct professor at Rockhurst University from 2006 to 2014.
This entry was posted in Regular Post and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Trayvon and Abdulrahman

  1. Leroy Seat says:

    Local Thinking Friend Kevin Payne sent the following comments by email (and I have standing approval from him to post here any comments he makes):

    “Even though I thought Zimmerman’s acquittal was justified, he did violate the teachings he received in his Concealed Carry class. (I have my concealed carry liscense, and we were taught, forcefully, that it is our responsibility to de-escalate the situation, and avoid a conflict if at all possible). Those teachings, of course, do not have the force of law, but had Zimmerman followed those teachings things would not have turned out as they did. At the very least, this case really wasn’t a very good example of a clear ‘self-defense’ situation, even though it does bring up a number of signficant issues regarding racism, profiling, and personal responsibility.

    “I do agree with you completely, though, on the drone issue. It’s incredible that a Democratic president has escalated this practice to such high levels, and that his administration justifies it completely. What we have now is an administration that can, for unsubstantiated reasons and without Congressional or Senate oversight, kill anyone it pleases, even a young boy that is a U.S. citizen. Strangely, few seem to care. I think this is terrifying, and needs to stop!”

  2. Leroy Seat says:

    Bob Carlson, also a local Thinking Friend who gave me permission to post his comments here, wrote:

    “Wow! Leroy! I did not know this story. I find it very troubling. Thanks for calling it to my attention. The military in our government continue to ignore international law and US law in an effort to make us ‘safe.’ How can we be ‘safe’ under a government that does not follow it’s own laws?”

  3. Leroy Seat says:

    A Thinking Friend who lives in Kentucky wrote,

    “Thanks for writing that blog, Leroy. The killing of Abdulrahman highlights the serious moral issues connected with the drones. We have let fear take control of our senses.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s